Four Reasons (and Remedies) for Weariness

Shortly after the pandemic travel bans lifted, my wife and I escaped to Puerto Rico. We were ready for a break. Like so many others, the accumulated stressors of family life, city life, church life, and our own social and emotional well-being had taken their toll, and we just needed to get away and exhale.

Then, when we finally arrived in paradise, something unexpected happened: we were angry. I mean really angry. Not at each other, per se—though we weren't the nicest to each other—but nothing seemed good enough. Our first dining experience wasn’t our favorite. The hot tub was cold. The hotel was loud. We spent the first couple of days reeling until some semblance of peace finally showed up.

Here's the thing: paradise wasn't the problem. The break wasn't the problem. I’m not even sure if there was a problem. But I do know the moment we had a chance to pause from the noise of ordinary life, we could finally hear a cry from within our interior lives.

That trip taught me something I've never forgotten: sometimes we don't know how tired we are until we rest. In other words, rest doesn't cure our weariness—it exposes it. It's like walking out of a loud concert into the quiet of the parking garage. The ringing in your ears isn't new. The silence just makes it perceptible.

Since then, I've noticed at least four reasons we get tired, and I've found that each brand of exhaustion needs its own remedy.

First, our hearts get tired when our loves are out of order.

The heart wears out not simply from doing too much, but from wanting too much from wrong things—or from carrying things it was never meant to carry: an image to maintain, an outcome to control, an approval to win. When our loves are disordered, even good things exhaust us, because we're asking them to do for us what only God can do.

St. Augustine famously prayed: "You have made us for yourself, and our heart is restless until it rests in you." The tired heart is a restless heart, and restlessness doesn't always look like pacing. Sometimes it looks like irritability with the people you love most, cynicism about work you once enjoyed, or a vague ache that nothing quite satisfies.

The remedy isn't more discipline. It's reordered desire. Tim and Michael Keller put it well: unmet longings "aren't a curse; they're a clue." A practice I've come back to again and again: when something disappoints or enrages me, I ask, "What was I actually hoping this (thing or person or vacation) would give me?" Then I take that longing to God before I take it anywhere else. Sometimes the most spiritual thing you can do with your tired heart is name what you've been asking it to carry.

Second, our minds get tired when we refuse to change them.

There’s a particular exhaustion that comes from thinking the same thought over and over again. Rumination is expensive. The mind that keeps circling the same story … I'm behind … I'm alone … it all depends on me … never gets to rest, because it never gets to be wrong. Its quieter cousin, dogmatism, is just as tiring: a settled answer has to be defended all day long.

A closed mind can’t rest. It’s motivated by fear, constantly ready to “armor up” and protect itself.

Scripture's word for the alternative is repentance. We usually reserve that word for behavior, but metanoia literally means "a change of mind." Paul says we're transformed "by the renewal of your mind,” not the reinforcement of it. And the Psalms teach us that saying open to God’s Spirit and truth, invites fresh discovery and intimacy with him. Like when David prays, "Search me, O God, and know my heart! ... See if there be any grievous way in me.”

Here's the surprise: embracing mystery doesn't wear the mind out—it lets the mind rest. We’re not God, and we never were supposed to be.

The remedy is holding our opinions with open hands. Name the sentence that's on repeat and ask: Is this what God says? Is this even true? Dogmatism says we must understand everything to rest. Mystery says we can rest because we don't have to. You see, an open and curioius mind isn’t the rejection of truth, it’s the posture of a son or daughter who really trusts their Heavenly Father.

Thrid, our bodies get tired when we overuse, underuse, or misuse them.

Our bodies get tired for good reasons—intense seasons, daily demands, and the simple fact that we are creatures, not machines. But we also get tired because we overuse, underuse, or misuse our bodies. We overuse them when we treat them like machines that must perform no matter what. We underuse them when we sink into isolation and lethargy. We misuse them when we feel ashamed of them. In every case, we sever the body from the rest of our personhood.

Even Jesus needed this kind of care. After he was tempted in the wilderness, his body depleted, "the devil left him, and behold, angels came and were ministering to him" (Matthew 4:11). If the Son of God received care for his body, it’s okay (and good) when we need the same.

The remedies here are wonderfully common but deeply spiritual: sleep, food, movement, and rhythm. "He gives to his beloved sleep" … which means your eight hours tonight is a gift, not a confession of weakness. And when the body is beyond tired, I've found breath prayers to be a quiet, embodied way of letting the peace of Christ minister rest (I wrote about this for my church recently).

Fourth, our souls get tired when we're disconnected from a larger story and identity.

This is, perhaps, the most mysterious of the four, because you can be well-rested, physically healthy, and even emotionally stable, and still be hollow. You can win on paper and feel fragmented underneath. Soul-tiredness is what happens when our work and our days detach from any larger story—when we've forgotten who we are and whose we are, so everything depends on us to keep it propped up.

Jesus's invitation isn’t "work harder for me" but "abide in me.” The soul rests when it remembers that identity is something we receive, not something we achieve—that we are loved children before we are useful workers, and that our ordinary lives are being folded into a story much older and much bigger than our ROIs and KPIs.

The remedy is abiding: a rule of life that keeps you connected to the Vine thorugh prayer, sabbath, community, and the daily practice of remembering whose you are before you remember what you're due.

Puerto Rico wasn't the problem. Taking a break wasn't the problem. In fact, there wasn't really a problem at all—there was a new discovery about how I'm made and how God desires to make me whole. Rest didn't ruin our vacation. It rescued it. It just didn't rescue us the way we expected: not by fixing our weariness, but by telling us the truth about it.

So if this finds you tired—and it probably does—don't just book another getaway and hope the beach fixes you. Get curious instead. Ask: what kind of tired am I? Then let the right remedy do its work. And if you want a partner in that discovery, that's literally what we do at Terracotta. Start with our 2-minute Fracture Check and find out where your tiredness is really coming from.

____________

ENDNOTES

  1. Augustine of Hippo, Confessions, Book 1, chapter 1: "You have made us for yourself, and our heart is restless until it rests in you."

  2. Tim and Michael Keller, The Stories We Live By: Seven Cultural Myths That Fail Us and the Story That Never Will (Zondervan, 2026). [Add page number once you can verify it against the book.]

  3. The Greek word translated "repentance" throughout the New Testament, metanoia (cf. Matthew 4:17; Acts 2:38), literally means "a change of mind" - a change of one's thinking that reshapes one's whole orientation.

  4. Romans 12:2: "Do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewal of your mind" (ESV).

  5. Psalm 139:23-24: "Search me, O God, and know my heart! Try me and know my thoughts! And see if there be any grievous way in me" (ESV).

  6. Matthew 4:11: "Then the devil left him, and behold, angels came and were ministering to him" (ESV).

  7. Psalm 127:2: "He gives to his beloved sleep" (ESV).

  8. On breath prayers: an ancient two-part prayer tradition associated with third-century desert Christians, in which a brief phrase of trust is prayed on the inhale and a phrase of surrender on the exhale. I recently wrote about this practice for my church; see "Prayer for a Tired Body" [link].

  9. John 15:4-5: "Abide in me, and I in you. As the branch cannot bear fruit by itself, unless it abides in the vine, neither can you, unless you abide in me. I am the vine; you are the branches" (ESV).

  10. The phrasing "identity is something we receive, not something we achieve" echoes the Kellers' argument in The Stories We Live By; see note 2.

Next
Next

What Does It Mean to Be Healthy?